What is it like to negotiate with Russian representatives regarding the conflict in Ukraine?
This question has generated considerable interest following multiple latest sessions of ceasefire talks, which until now seemed to produce minimal fruit four years after the comprehensive invasion.
A further round of American-facilitated discussions is likely to occur in Geneva in the coming days. Ahead of it, an important member of Ukrainian President Zelensky's negotiating team, Sergiy Kyslytsya, who has been involved in recent direct military talks, has provided his perspective.
As stated by the negotiator, these dealings are business-like and mostly devoid of the type of political and rhetorical grandstanding seen in other forums by Russian leadership.
"Military officials possess a superior understanding of what is going on in the battlefield," he stated in a conversation earlier this week.
"It's another thing whether they [the Russians] are able, or not, of reporting [back] directly…without cooking or changing the facts," he added.
It is not an simple thing to attempt to end a war. The nature of the battlefield in eastern Ukraine - where thousands of drones operate and kill over a huge so-called "contested area" separating the two sides, while 200,000 Ukrainian civilians still reside in the "fortress belt" urban areas of the eastern region - makes the practical business of separation highly complex.
"You have to have a clear framework of rules and procedures," the diplomat explained, "along with a method to confirm and monitor."
The Involvement of External Mediators
A great deal of this work, he said, is finished, thanks in part to the direct participation of US representatives, including General Alexus Grynkewich and Dan Driscoll.
It's obviously against Kyiv's interest to criticise envoys of the American government, but when Kyslytsya praises the American team for its work, he comes across as genuine.
"We have to credit the Americans for their commitment and their patience," he states, "since they attend the meetings non-stop. They don't only observe…they ask questions and they listen to our responses."
The negotiator was equally complimentary about the contributions of the former president's adviser, whom he described as "experienced", and billionaire envoy the special representative, whom he characterized as "a much wiser person than the caricature portrayal you see in the press".
The US, he asserted, will undertake a key role in monitoring any potential truce, with resources including orbital and other forms of advanced surveillance.
"It is necessary to have someone who will play the role of an arbitrator, for the reason that if there is a breach there should be a third party that is solid [and] authoritative."
Past and Present Oversight Realities
For eight years before Russia's full-scale offensive in 2022, this monitoring role was played by the OSCE - a body whose restricted means and absence of enforcement mechanisms made it mostly unable of preventing an escalation.
"That was no small feat [for them] just to have a couple of drones flying above the territory," he commented. "It resembles the Flintstones period compared to what we have now."
By contrast, latest analyses indicate that up to twelve thousand drones are operating over the single city of a frontline city at any one time.
A Personal Account on Confronting the Opposition
When asked how he managed to negotiate directly from emissaries representing a head of state in the Kremlin who has been willing to expend more than a million-plus of his own men to subjugate its neighbor, Kyslytsya, with extensive UN experience, offered his answer.
He explained that he'd had a long time of experience.
"I witnessed much worse. I served five years in New York, three of them prior to the major war. I would be present with the enemy on a regular basis."
A particular night is seared in his memory: 23 February 2022.
During an urgent Security Council meeting, called to address the urgent crisis in Ukraine, the diplomat got word that his country was being assaulted.
At the same time, far away to the eastward in the capital, initial far-off explosions signaled as the total assault on Ukraine began.
During moments of intense tension, the ambassador attempted to get his Russian counterpart, Vassily Nebenzia, to contact his superior, the Russian foreign minister, to obtain assurances that Moscow's forces would not invade.
"I have stated all I know now," Nebenzia replied, according to his Ukrainian colleague. "I'm not going to disturb Minister Lavrov at this time."
Everyone's lives changed at that moment. The diplomat stayed at the UN for another three years before going back to the Ukrainian capital.
The Path Forward
If the delegations meet again in Switzerland on Thursday, he will participate, still working through the details and mechanics of a ceasefire but anticipating all the while for the most important element of the jigsaw to be resolved.
"Hostilities could be ended by just one call of one person to his top general," he stated.
"However, the Kremlin dictator [Vladimir Putin] is not up to stopping the conflict for the time being."